October 19th, 2004

Shinchilla

(no subject)

maeglinyedi has a very thoughtful poll and some questions going on about Voldemort here.. Even if you aren't part of the Crazy Death Eaters fanclub, some of the questions are intriguing for the canon in general, it's worth a look.

In particular, "Do you think Voldemort would have won the first war, had it not been for Harry 'defeating him'?" made me think. I sort of wanted to say 'yes' because the whole scenario involves the destruction of a core group of the Order.

Collapse )

Clearly we're supposed to think that James and Sirius were hot stuff, but assigning import to that when not in light of Harry's Voldie Smiting Powers is tricky business.
  • Current Music
    let go-frou frou